Security Deposit Disputes: Key Case Decisions in Prince Edward Island

Security deposit disputes are one of the most common issues between tenants and landlords in Prince Edward Island. Understanding how previous cases have been decided, what documentation is required, and where to seek help can make a significant difference for tenants facing a withheld deposit. This article highlights recent decisions, relevant laws, and step-by-step actions that Prince Edward Island tenants can take to protect their rights and recover deposits fairly.

Who Oversees Rental Deposit Disputes in Prince Edward Island?

The Office of the Director of Residential Rental Property is responsible for hearing residential tenancy disputes, including those related to security deposits. Tenants and landlords alike must follow the procedures set out by this tribunal when contesting a deposit matter.

Relevant Legislation for Tenants

All security deposit matters in PEI are governed by the Residential Property Act (Prince Edward Island)^[1]. This legislation details:

• Maximum allowed deposit (usually no more than one month's rent)
• Reasons a deposit can be withheld (e.g., unpaid rent, damage beyond normal wear and tear)
• Timelines for returning deposits (within 10 days of tenancy end unless there is a dispute)

Notable Security Deposit Decisions: What Can Tenants Learn?

Several recent cases help clarify what counts as a valid reason to withhold a deposit, and what evidence both sides must provide. Here are some key takeaways:

• Damage vs. Normal Wear: Tribunals often side with tenants if a landlord claims damages that are actually normal wear and tear. Clear documentation of the property’s condition at move-in and move-out helps prove your case. For an overview of best practices, see the Guide to the Initial Rental Property Inspection for Tenants.
• Timely Return: Landlords must return the security deposit within the legislated period unless they formally file for damages. Failure to comply can result in an order for the landlord to pay back the deposit, sometimes with interest.
• Burden of Proof: The landlord must demonstrate why any amount should be withheld. Photos, inspection reports, and correspondence are important evidence.

Practical Example: PEI Tribunal Decisions

In a typical scenario, a tenant moved out and the landlord alleged damage to the floors. The tenant provided move-in inspection photos showing the floors were already scratched. The tribunal found in favour of the tenant, ordering the deposit returned. This kind of evidence-based outcome is common.

Tip: Document your rental’s condition and keep all records of communication and payments. These items are essential if a security deposit dispute arises.

Forms & Applying for Return of Your Deposit

If your deposit is being withheld unfairly, tenants can formally request a hearing with the Office of the Director of Residential Rental Property. The application process uses Form 6: Application by Tenant for Dispute Resolution (Form 6):

• When to use: If your landlord has not returned your security deposit within 10 days, or you dispute deductions
• How to use: Complete Form 6 and submit it by email, mail, or in person to the Office within one year of the tenancy ending
• Practical example: A tenant applies using Form 6 after the landlord withholds the full deposit, claiming excessive cleaning costs. Both sides present evidence at the hearing, which results in a partial return based on the documentation provided.

Steps for Tenants: What to Do When a Deposit Dispute Arises

• Contact your landlord in writing to clarify deposit deductions
• Gather all documentation: lease, inspection reports, photos, communications
• If unresolved, complete and submit Form 6
• Prepare your evidence for the hearing

Following these steps improves your chances of a fair result and a timely return of your funds.

Learn More About Deposits and Related Tenant Rights

Tenants can find more detailed information on security deposits and their rights at Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know. For specific information about local regulations, see Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

To explore rentals and compare housing options, Find rental homes across Canada on Houseme.

FAQ: Security Deposits in Prince Edward Island

1. How quickly must a landlord return my security deposit in PEI?
   The landlord must return the deposit within 10 days after the tenancy ends unless a dispute is filed with the tribunal.
2. Can a landlord deduct cleaning costs from my deposit?
   They may deduct reasonable cleaning costs beyond normal wear and tear. Excessive or routine cleaning is not valid for deduction.
3. What if my landlord doesn’t return my deposit or provide reasons?
   You can file Form 6 with the Office of the Director of Residential Rental Property and present evidence supporting your case.
4. Is interest required on returned deposits?
   Yes, deposits must be returned with interest as specified by law. Check current rates with the Office of the Director.
5. Can I appeal a decision about my security deposit?
   Appeals are allowed within 20 days of the written order, using the formal appeal process explained by the tribunal.

Summary: What PEI Tenants Should Remember

• Document your rental’s condition at move-in and move-out
• If there’s a dispute, apply promptly through the tribunal using official forms
• Clear evidence is the key to recovering your deposit fairly

Many disputes are resolved once tenants understand their rights and present well-organized documentation to the proper authorities.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Office of the Director of Residential Rental Property — Official tribunal governing security deposit disputes
• Residential Property Claims Information for Tenants
• Free legal advice may be available through PEI's Legal Aid

---

1. Residential Property Act (Prince Edward Island): Full Text of the Law

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy