PEI Tenant Wins: Quiet Enjoyment Case Law & Rights

Tenants in Prince Edward Island have a legal right to 'quiet enjoyment' of their rental homes. Recent case law in PEI demonstrates how this right is interpreted and enforced, offering reassurance—and practical steps—to renters who face disturbances or intrusions in their living space.

What Does 'Quiet Enjoyment' Mean for PEI Tenants?

In PEI, the right to quiet enjoyment means your rental must remain peaceful and your privacy must be respected by landlords and anyone acting on their behalf. This right is guaranteed by the Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act.^[1]

• Freedom from unreasonable landlord entry
• No harassment or persistent, unnecessary interruptions
• Protection from excessive noise or disruptive maintenance

This isn't just about noise; it covers privacy, access, and overall ability to live comfortably without repeated issues caused by the landlord or their agents.

Case Law: Tenant Wins on Quiet Enjoyment Claims

There are several cases before the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC) – Rental Office where tenants have successfully claimed breach of quiet enjoyment. These cases help clarify the law for all renters in PEI:

• Example: A tenant proved that the landlord entered the property without proper notice multiple times, violating the required 24-hour written notice.
• Result: The Rental Office awarded compensation and ordered the landlord to follow proper notice procedures—for instance, using approved forms and times for entry.

The Rental Office analyzes these cases based on the legislation and evidence provided. Successful tenant claims often involve keeping detailed records of disturbances and communications.

Relevant Legislation and Official Forms

• Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act: This Act establishes your right to quiet enjoyment. Review the full Act here.^[1]
• Form 6: Tenant's Application for Order
  • When to use: If you believe your quiet enjoyment has been breached and discussions with your landlord haven't resolved the issue, you can apply to IRAC’s Rental Office using Form 6.
  • Example: Suppose your landlord enters your unit repeatedly without proper notice—even after you’ve asked them to stop. You can file Form 6 to request an official decision.
  • Official Form 6 Download

How Tenants Can Take Action in PEI

If your right to quiet enjoyment is not respected, try these steps before turning to a formal application:

• Politely inform your landlord (in writing) about the problem and request it stop.
• Reference your rights under the Rental of Residential Property Act.
• If the landlord does not resolve the issue, submit Form 6: Tenant’s Application for Order to the IRAC Rental Office with your evidence.

In many situations, these actions lead to a quick resolution. If your problem relates to landlord obligations, like essential repairs or respecting your privacy, you can also consult the resource Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained for more about your legal protections and landlord duties.

Preventing and Resolving Quiet Enjoyment Issues

Most disputes about quiet enjoyment can be resolved through direct communication and awareness of rights. To minimize issues:

• Ensure you have a clear, signed rental agreement
• Document all landlord communications
• Conduct an initial property inspection upon move-in
• Learn how to Handle Complaints in Your Rental: A Tenant’s Guide

If disruption continues, government tribunals provide effective remedies for tenants.

For more information specific to your province, visit Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

To browse safe, quality rentals and avoid problematic situations in the first place, Browse apartments for rent in Canada.

FAQs: Quiet Enjoyment and Tenant Rights in PEI

1. What should I do if my landlord enters my apartment without notice?
   Document every entry, notify your landlord in writing about the legal requirement for 24-hour written notice, and if the problem continues, apply to the IRAC Rental Office using Form 6.
2. Can noise from other tenants count as a breach of quiet enjoyment?
   Yes, excessive and ongoing noise from neighbours may qualify. Inform your landlord and IRAC if needed, providing detailed records.
3. What is the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission's role?
   IRAC's Rental Office handles all tenancy disputes, including quiet enjoyment cases, and issues legally binding orders based on the facts.
4. Does my landlord have to warn me before every entry?
   Yes, with some exceptions (like emergencies), your landlord must give at least 24 hours' written notice before entering your rental unit.

Key Takeaways for PEI Tenants

• Your right to quiet enjoyment gives you strong protections from intrusions and unreasonable disturbances.
• Keep records and use official forms to pursue your rights when needed.
• The IRAC Rental Office is your resource for enforcing these rights under PEI law.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• IRAC Rental Office (Prince Edward Island) – File applications, download forms, and access tenant guides.
• PEI Justice & Public Safety – Landlord and Tenant Matters
• CMHC Rental Resources – National information for renters and landlords.

---

1. Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy