What should I do if my landlord serves an eviction notice without a good reason?

You should submit an Application for Hearing (Form 2) to the Residential Tenancy Office to dispute the eviction. If the notice does not meet legal requirements or lacks valid grounds, it can be overturned.

How does the tribunal decide if a landlord can keep my deposit?

The tribunal looks at whether your landlord gave you a written statement of damages within ten days after you moved out. If not, you may be entitled to the full deposit back.

Are there rules for how much my rent can go up each year in PEI?

Yes, landlords must follow government guidelines for the maximum increase and must give at least three months' written notice before raising rent.

What urgent repairs must my landlord do right away?

Landlords must fix any urgent health or safety concerns—like broken heat or major plumbing problems—immediately to comply with PEI law.

Key Tenant Rights Case Decisions in Prince Edward Island

Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Prince Edward Island published: June 19, 2025

As a tenant in Prince Edward Island, understanding how legal precedents shape your rights can give you confidence when facing issues like eviction, rent increases, or repairs. Over the years, several important case decisions and tribunal rulings have clarified what landlords and tenants can—and cannot—do under PEI rental law.

Who Handles Tenant Disputes in PEI?

In Prince Edward Island, rental housing disputes are handled by the Residential Tenancy Office, under the guidance of the Office of the Director of Residential Tenancy. This tribunal reviews complaints, conducts hearings, and issues decisions affecting landlord and tenant rights.

The main law governing rentals in PEI is the Rental of Residential Property Act^[1], which lays out the rules for rent, evictions, security deposits, repairs, and more.

Landmark Prince Edward Island Tenant Cases and Their Impact

Tribunal and court decisions have helped clarify key areas of tenant rights, particularly when it comes to security deposits, rent increases, eviction notices, and property maintenance. Here's how these cases might affect you as a tenant.

Security Deposits—When Can They Be Withheld?

The Residential Tenancy Office has repeatedly emphasized landlords must follow strict procedures before keeping any part of a security deposit. For example, in several case rulings, landlords were ordered to return deposits when they failed to provide a written statement of damages within ten days of the tenant moving out. This requirement protects you from unfair deductions and ensures transparency.

For a complete breakdown of deposit rules—including what landlords can deduct for—see Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

Rent Increases—Legal Limits and Tribunal Review

PEI has specific rules about when and how landlords can raise your rent. Some key cases have focused on whether the correct notice period was given (three months in writing), and if increases followed guideline percentages. In cases where landlords failed to meet notice requirements, tenants were able to have the increase declared void—and only had to pay the original rent amount.

Evictions—Grounds and Proper Notice

Cases before the Director of Residential Tenancy often turn on whether the landlord had valid grounds to evict (such as non-payment, damage, or repeated violations) and if the Notice to Vacate (Form 4) followed prescribed timelines. If landlords skip steps or use an incorrect form, the eviction is usually set aside, giving tenants more time or a chance to remedy the situation.

Always review any eviction notice you receive. If you believe the notice was improperly served or not justified, you can apply for a hearing to challenge it.

Maintenance and Repairs—Tenant Health and Safety

Some precedent-setting decisions have required landlords to address significant health or safety issues—like lack of heat, pest infestations, or unsafe wiring—promptly. The tribunal has made it clear that essential repairs can't be delayed and tenants may be entitled to a rent reduction if conditions are unlivable.

If you're facing these issues, Health and Safety Issues Every Tenant Should Know When Renting covers steps and rights for PEI tenants.

Forms and Practical Steps: What Tenants Should Know

Application for Hearing (Form 2): Used to ask the Residential Tenancy Office to decide any dispute—for example, if you want your deposit returned or to challenge an eviction.
Download Form 2.
Example: If your landlord withholds your deposit without proper explanation, you would use Form 2 to start a hearing.
Notice to Vacate (Form 4): The official eviction notice form. Landlords must use this to begin the eviction process for valid reasons.
See Form 4 and instructions.
Example: If you receive a Form 4, you can appeal by submitting a Form 2.

Every situation may be different, but these forms are central to protecting your rights at every step of a rental dispute in PEI.

What These Cases Mean for Tenants

These landmark case decisions reinforce:

Your right to fair treatment in security deposit deductions
Clear rules for how and when rent can increase
Formal notice and just cause requirements for eviction
The duty of landlords to quickly address serious repair and safety problems

For a summary of tenant and landlord rights unique to the province, visit Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

Want to find a new place or see what’s available nearby? Find rental homes across Canada on Houseme and discover listings that fit your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tenant Case Law in PEI

What happens if my landlord tries to evict me without proper notice?
If you receive an eviction notice that does not follow the rules (wrong form, not enough notice, or no valid reason), you can appeal to the Residential Tenancy Office. Most improper evictions are overturned if challenged in time.
How can I dispute a deduction from my security deposit?
You can file an Application for Hearing (Form 2) with the tribunal if you believe your security deposit has been wrongfully withheld. Be sure to include evidence like move-out photos or emails.
What repairs must landlords complete immediately?
Landlords are required to fix urgent health and safety issues promptly, such as heating, plumbing, or severe pest infestations. Failure to do so can result in rent reductions or orders to make repairs.
Are there limits to how much my landlord can raise my rent?
Yes, annual rent increases must not exceed government guidelines, and landlords must give at least three months' written notice using the correct process.

Conclusion

Case decisions by the Residential Tenancy Office ensure PEI tenants have strong protections against unfair evictions, rent hikes, and safety lapses.
Always check that landlords follow official notice and form requirements—most cases are won or lost on these details.
Use official forms and know your right to appeal any decision affecting your home.

Being informed gives you the power to protect your home and handle disputes with confidence.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

Residential Tenancy Office (PEI): File forms, ask questions, or resolve disputes.
Rental of Residential Property Act Guide: Easy-to-read overview of tenant and landlord rights.
Tenant support services: Local legal aid and community organizations can offer free advice or representation.