Tenant Rights: Pet and Smoking Damage Accusations in Nova Scotia

If you've been accused by your landlord of damages caused by pets or smoking in Nova Scotia, it's important to understand your rights, responsibilities, and the steps you can take. Navigating rental disputes can feel overwhelming, but tenants in Nova Scotia are protected by clear laws and can challenge unfair claims while ensuring their home remains safe and comfortable.

Understanding Pet and Smoking Damage Accusations

Landlords can ask tenants to pay for damages beyond normal wear and tear, including those allegedly caused by pets or tobacco smoke. However, accusations must be supported by clear evidence, and tenants have the right to dispute them through a formal process with the Residential Tenancy Program of Nova Scotia.

What the Law Says: Nova Scotia Tenancy Legislation

The Residential Tenancies Act (Nova Scotia) governs all landlord-tenant relations in the province. This law outlines which damages a tenant can be held responsible for and the process for resolving disputes.¹

Common Examples of Pet or Smoking Damages

• Pet stains or odours in carpets, floors, or walls
• Chewed or scratched doors, trim, or blinds
• Cigarette burns, heavy smoke residue, or persistent odours

Normal wear and tear — such as minor scratches, faded paint, or worn flooring from regular use — is typically not considered damage.

What To Do If Accused of Damages

If your landlord claims you caused damage with a pet or by smoking, don't panic. Here's a step-by-step overview for tenants in Nova Scotia:

• Request Written Details: Ask your landlord to provide written documentation, including photos, dates, and a breakdown of alleged damages and repair costs.
• Refer to Inspection Records: Compare the claims to your Guide to the Initial Rental Property Inspection for Tenants and any move-in or move-out inspection forms.
• Document Your Own Evidence: Take your own photos or videos and keep copies of all communications.
• Negotiate If Possible: If you agree with some claims, try to reach a fair settlement directly with your landlord, but never pay for damages you did not cause.
• Dispute Unfair Claims: If you feel the damages are being exaggerated or not your responsibility, you can file an application with the Residential Tenancy Program.

Key Forms for Disputing Damage Claims

• Form K: Security Deposit Claim Application — Tenants use this to dispute a landlord's claim to part or all of the security deposit.
  Example: If your landlord withholds your deposit citing smoke smell, but you have before-and-after photos showing a clean unit, submit this form.
  View and download Form K on the Nova Scotia government site
• Form J: Application to Director — Used to resolve broader tenancy disputes, including disagreements over responsibility for damages.
  Example: If negotiation fails, use Form J to request a formal hearing.
  Download Form J from the official source

Your Rights and Landlord Obligations

Tenants cannot be charged for "routine cleaning" or normal wear and tear. Landlords can deduct proven, above-normal damages, but not for general upkeep or issues pre-dating your tenancy. The law protects you from arbitrary charges, and you have the right to challenge any claims through the official tribunal process.

For a broader overview of legal expectations for tenants and landlords in Nova Scotia, see Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained.

Protecting Your Security Deposit

If a dispute arises, your security deposit cannot be kept unless damages are proven at the tribunal. To learn more about deposits and your rights, see Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

If you're searching for a new, pet-friendly rental, you can Search pet-friendly rentals on Houseme.ca to find options across Nova Scotia and Canada.

For complete provincial details, see Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Nova Scotia.

FAQ: Tenant Rights and Damage Disputes in Nova Scotia

1. Can a landlord keep my deposit for normal wear and tear from my pet?
   No. Landlords can only charge for damages that go beyond reasonable use. Normal wear, like light scuffs or minor fur, is not considered damage.
2. What if my lease says no smoking but a guest smoked in my unit?
   Your landlord may still hold you responsible for breaches of the lease. If damage occurred, you can dispute any exaggerated claims with evidence and by applying to the Residential Tenancy Program.
3. How do I challenge a damage accusation I disagree with?
   Keep all your evidence and use Form K or Form J to formally dispute the charge through the Residential Tenancy Program.
4. Do I have to allow my landlord to inspect for damages with pets or smoke?
   Yes, with proper notice, landlords are permitted to inspect for damages. They cannot enter without notice unless in emergency.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways for Tenants

• Accusations of damage must be supported by evidence and can be disputed.
• Always participate in inspections and keep records throughout your tenancy.
• If a dispute cannot be resolved, use the official forms and processes to protect your rights and your deposit.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Residential Tenancy Program, Nova Scotia — Guidance, forms, and dispute resolution
• Legal Information Society of Nova Scotia: legalinfo.org
• Dalhousie Legal Aid Service: dal.ca/faculty/law/dlas.html
• General support: 1-800-670-4357 (toll-free)

---

1. Residential Tenancies Act (Nova Scotia)
2. Nova Scotia Residential Tenancy Program (Official Tribunal)
3. Form K: Security Deposit Claim Application
4. Form J: Application to Director

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy