Tenant Rights If Accused of Damages from Pets or Smoking (NWT)

Being accused of causing damage to your rental unit by pets or smoking can be stressful. In the Northwest Territories (NWT), both tenants and landlords have specific rights and responsibilities under the Residential Tenancies Act (NWT). Knowing what steps to take, what proof is needed, and what official forms apply can help you protect your rights and resolve any issues fairly.

How Landlords Handle Alleged Damages from Pets or Smoking

Landlords in the NWT may allege that tenants, their guests, or their pets have caused damage beyond regular wear and tear—especially from pets (like chewed carpets, scratched floors) or from smoking (including lingering odour or stains). If this happens, landlords can seek compensation—but they must follow proper legal procedures.

• Written notice: Landlords must generally provide written notice outlining the alleged damages and expected repairs or cleaning costs.
• Proof required: They must be able to show evidence (such as inspection reports or dated photos) that damages exceed normal wear and tear.
• Security deposit deductions: Landlords may propose deducting amounts from the security deposit for repairs.

Your Rights and Options as a Tenant

Tenants do not have to accept all claims for damages. The Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Northwest Territories provide important protections:

• The landlord can only claim for costs that go beyond ordinary wear and tear.
• You have the right to request proof (e.g., photos, receipts, inspection forms).
• You may contest unreasonable or unsubstantiated deductions from your security deposit.
• You can apply to the NWT Rental Office (the official tribunal for residential tenancies) for dispute resolution if agreement isn't reached.

Before moving in or out, conduct a joint inspection with your landlord and complete the official Move-In/Move-Out Inspection Report. This helps avoid disputes later.

Key Forms for Damage Disputes (Pets or Smoking)

Familiarizing yourself with official forms is crucial if you're dealing with damage accusations:

• Condition Inspection Report (Form 9): Used for joint inspections at move-in and move-out. Lists the condition of the unit, noting existing damage and cleanliness. Always keep a signed copy. Access Form 9 here. For example, if you’re being accused of pet-related carpet stains, check your move-in report for any pre-existing damage notes.
• Application to Rental Officer (Form 2): If you disagree with a landlord's damage/deduction claim, you can file this form to request a hearing with the NWT Rental Office. Access Form 2 here. For example, if your landlord keeps the deposit for "smoke odour" you did not cause, submit this application to challenge the deduction.

Follow official instructions on each form, and always provide clear details plus supporting evidence (inspection reports, photos, receipts).

What Counts as Damage vs. Normal Wear and Tear?

It's important to know the difference between damage and "normal wear and tear," as only the former can be claimed by your landlord:

• Normal wear and tear: Includes minor scuffs, faded paint, carpet flattening, etc.
• Damage: Includes burns, holes, stains, or extensive odours caused by smoke or pets.

If disputes arise, inspection reports are the main evidence. For clarity on this process, see the Guide to the Initial Rental Property Inspection for Tenants.

Security Deposits and Damage Claims

Landlords are allowed to use part or all of your security deposit to pay for proven damages. However, the rules are strict:

• The landlord must provide an itemized statement showing each deduction and related proof (receipts, before/after photos, professional cleaning quotes).
• If these requirements aren't met, you can contest the deductions via the Rental Office.
• Full return of your deposit is required if no proven additional damages are found. For more about deposits, visit Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

For smoke or pet damages, look for clear documentation like move-in photos or reports.

Health and Safety: Smoke, Pets, and Your Rental

Damage caused by smoke may also raise health or safety concerns, especially if excessive residue, odour, or allergens are left in the unit. Noise or odour issues from pets, as well as pest infestations, may also be argued as health risks. For resources about health and safety standards, see Health and Safety Issues Every Tenant Should Know When Renting.

Always communicate in writing and keep records of all correspondence and evidence related to damage allegations. This will help you if you need to dispute charges before the Rental Office.

What to Do If You Receive a Damage Notice: Step-by-Step

If you’re served a written notice about alleged damages from pets or smoking, stay calm and take these practical steps:

• Ask for evidence—photos, reports, or receipts.
• Compare with your signed move-in inspection report and photos. Note any discrepancies.
• If you disagree, communicate this to your landlord in writing, providing your own evidence.
• If the landlord withholds your deposit or requests extra payment without evidence—or you believe the charges are unfair—apply to the NWT Rental Office using Form 2.

If you acted promptly and have documentation, you are more likely to achieve a fair outcome.

For a broader search of pet-friendly and smoke-free rentals across Canada, Search pet-friendly rentals on Houseme.ca.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can a landlord keep my deposit for cigarette smell even if I smoked outside?
   Cigarette smoke odour documented inside the unit may result in deductions. However, landlords must prove the odour is extraordinary and not usual wear; always compare with move-in records.
2. What if pet damage was noted in the initial inspection?
   If pet-related damage existed before you moved in and was officially recorded, your landlord cannot hold you responsible for it at move-out. Signed reports are your main evidence.
3. How do I dispute unfair damage claims?
   Collect your inspection reports and evidence, communicate with your landlord in writing, and if not resolved, apply to the NWT Rental Office for a decision using Form 2.
4. Are pets allowed in all rentals?
   No. Your lease or rental agreement must specify if pets are permitted. Breaching a no-pets clause can result in further action, so check your agreement and talk to your landlord.
5. Can I ask for an official property inspection for disputed damages?
   Yes. Tenants and landlords should both participate in move-out inspections using the Condition Inspection Report (Form 9). If there’s disagreement, the Rental Office can help resolve it.

Key Takeaways for Tenants

• Tenants in the Northwest Territories have clear rights when facing damage claims—always request and keep evidence.
• Security deposit deductions must be itemized and justified.
• Use the NWT Rental Office and official forms to resolve disputes.

Understanding these differences and steps can help prevent or resolve most damage-related conflicts.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• NWT Rental Office – Tenant information, applications, official forms, and dispute resolution
• Residential Tenancies Act (NWT) – Full text of the law
• NWT Association of Communities – Local tenant advocacy and support

---

1. Residential Tenancies Act (NWT): Full Act and Regulations
2. NWT Rental Office (official tribunal): Tenant and Landlord Information
3. Condition Inspection Report (Form 9): Official PDF
4. Application to Rental Officer (Form 2): Official PDF

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy