Key Deposit Rules for Manitoba Tenants: What Is Legal?

Many tenants in Manitoba are asked for a key deposit at the start of a new rental. Understanding whether key deposits are legal, and what your protections are, is essential for a smooth tenancy. This article explains Manitoba’s rules around key deposits, your rights as a renter, and what steps you can take if you have concerns.

Can Landlords Ask for Key Deposits in Manitoba?

In Manitoba, the law is clear about which deposits landlords can request from tenants. Under The Residential Tenancies Act (Manitoba), landlords are allowed to ask for a security deposit (sometimes called a damage deposit), but additional deposits—like key deposits—are strictly regulated.

• Key deposits are only legal if:
  • The amount charged is equal to the actual cost of replacing the key (not more)
  • The deposit is fully refundable when the key is returned at the end of the tenancy
• Key deposits cannot be used as extra security deposits or to charge for normal wear and tear

This rule helps keep the total move-in costs predictable for tenants and prevents unfair charges.

How Does a Key Deposit Differ from a Security Deposit?

While both involve initial payments, these deposits serve different purposes:

• Security deposit: Covers damages beyond normal wear and tear; must be no more than half a month’s rent
• Key deposit: Only covers the actual replacement cost of the key; not a catch-all damage deposit

For a full explanation of legal deposit types, see Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

What Happens If a Landlord Charges Too Much for a Key Deposit?

If a landlord asks for more than the replacement cost, or makes the deposit non-refundable even when you return the key, they are not following Manitoba law. In this case, tenants have a right to raise the issue and seek a refund.

How to Dispute an Unlawful Key Deposit

If a dispute arises, tenants can apply to Manitoba’s Residential Tenancies Branch (RTB), which oversees landlord-tenant matters. The RTB can order the landlord to refund any unlawful or excessive deposit.

Relevant Forms and How to Use Them

If you need to file a dispute over a key deposit:

• Form Name: Application for Order of Possession or Collection (RTB Form 3)
• When to use: If the landlord refuses to refund your key deposit after you return the key, use Form 3 to ask the RTB for a ruling
• How to file:
  • Fill out RTB Form 3: Application
  • Attach copies of your lease, deposit receipts, and any communication about the key deposit
  • Submit the form by mail, in person, or online via the RTB

Timely action helps ensure you get back any deposit you’re owed.

Your Rights and Protections Under Manitoba Law

The Residential Tenancies Act clearly states your protections regarding deposits and fees. Manitoba’s RTB enforces compliance, resolving disputes between landlords and tenants.

For a detailed look at rental rules in Manitoba, including deposits and repair responsibilities, visit Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Manitoba.

Other Common Questions About Deposits and Move-In Costs

Moving into a new rental often involves multiple payments and checks. To make this process easier, read Essential Tips for Tenants When Moving Into a New Rental Home for advice on protecting your finances at move-in, handling your first inspection, and dealing with deposits.

If you’re searching for a new apartment or want a better rental experience, Browse apartments for rent in Canada to see trusted listings for tenants.

Frequently Asked Questions About Key Deposits in Manitoba

1. Can my landlord keep my key deposit if I return the key?
   No. If you return the key, your landlord must refund your key deposit. They can only keep it if you lost the key and the deposit amount matches the replacement cost.
2. What should I do if my landlord charges more than the cost of a new key?
   Politely request a breakdown of the fee, referencing your rights under the Residential Tenancies Act. If they refuse, you can file a dispute with the Residential Tenancies Branch.
3. Are electronic fob deposits treated the same as key deposits?
   Yes, the law treats key fobs or electronic entry devices the same as regular keys. Deposits for these must also reflect their actual replacement cost.
4. Can the landlord use the key deposit for damages to the unit?
   No. Key deposits can only be used for lost or unreturned keys—never for property damage.
5. Are there limits to how much can be charged for all move-in deposits?
   Yes. Security deposits can’t exceed half a month’s rent, and all deposits—including key deposits—must be reasonable and only reflect actual costs. Learn more in Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

Key Takeaways for Manitoba Tenants

• Key deposits are legal only if they equal the replacement cost of the key or fob
• Landlords must refund the deposit when keys are returned at end of tenancy
• If you’re overcharged or denied a refund, apply to the Residential Tenancies Branch for help

Being informed and keeping records protects your rights and your money during your tenancy.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Residential Tenancies Branch (RTB) – Official government body for tenant-landlord matters, forms, and complaints in Manitoba
• RTB Forms – Download forms for disputes and other applications
• Manitoba Housing – Public resources on rental housing and tenant support
• Tenant advocacy: Contact Legal Aid Manitoba or the Manitoba Tenants Union for free or low-cost help

---

1. Residential Tenancies Act, C.C.S.M. c. R119. Read the Residential Tenancies Act (Manitoba).
2. Manitoba Residential Tenancies Branch official forms. Access RTB Forms and instructions.
3. Government of Manitoba: Residential Tenancies Branch - Tenant and Landlord Guide.

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy