Can Tenants Be Charged for Emergency Repairs in Prince Edward Island?

Emergencies can strike any rental home in Prince Edward Island, from burst pipes to broken heaters in winter. But when repairs must be made quickly, can tenants be held responsible for the cost? Understanding your rights under PEI’s rental laws can help you avoid being unfairly charged and ensure your home remains safe.

Who Is Responsible for Emergency Repairs in PEI?

In Prince Edward Island, landlords are legally required to maintain rental properties in a good, safe condition according to the Rental of Residential Property Act¹. Generally, this means landlords pay for emergency repairs—unless the tenant caused the damage through negligence or misuse.

• Landlord’s duties: Ensure plumbing, heating, electrical, and structural elements are safe and functional.
• Tenant’s duties: Keep the unit reasonably clean, report problems, and avoid damage through carelessness.

The Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained can give you a detailed overview of your responsibilities under the Act.

What Counts as an ‘Emergency’?

Emergencies typically include sudden repairs needed to prevent harm or significant property damage, such as:

• Flooding or serious leaks
• No heat during winter
• Broken windows making your unit unsafe
• Sewer backup or non-working toilets

If immediate attention is required to protect health or safety, it’s usually considered an emergency.

What to Do If an Emergency Repair Is Needed

Always contact your landlord or property manager right away if an urgent repair is required. If you can't reach them in a reasonable time and waiting would cause more damage, PEI law lets tenants arrange the repair themselves—but only for true emergencies.

If you arrange your own emergency repair, keep copies of all communications, photos, and receipts. Only call qualified professionals, and notify your landlord as soon as possible.

PEI’s Process for Emergency Repairs

If the landlord can’t be reached and you must act:

• Arrange only the minimum work required to address the emergency
• Document your attempts to contact the landlord
• Give the landlord a copy of the receipt and request reimbursement

If a landlord refuses to pay for an eligible emergency repair, you may apply to the PEI Rental Office (the provincial tribunal for rental disputes).

Can You Be Charged for Emergency Repairs?

Tenants are not responsible for the cost of emergency repairs unless the problem was caused by their own negligence or intentional damage. If you did not cause the issue and followed proper steps, your landlord cannot deduct repair costs from your rent or security deposit.

However, if it's proven that you (or your guest) caused the emergency by accident or carelessness, your landlord may charge you. This includes actions like flushing unsuitable items into the plumbing or damaging fire alarms.

If you have questions about how deposits might be affected after a repair, visit Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know.

Forms and Legal Steps for PEI Tenants

If your landlord disputes the repair bill and refuses reimbursement, you can file an application with the PEI Rental Office. The key form is:

• Application to the Director (Form 2A): Used to resolve disagreements about who pays for repairs. Fill in the details of your situation, attach proof (receipts, messages), and submit it to the Rental Office. Access Form 2A and instructions here.

For more about repair issues and your rights in emergencies, see Emergency Situations and Repairs: Tenant Rights and Responsibilities.

Key Tenant Protections

• Landlords may not evict you or charge extra simply for requesting or arranging a necessary emergency repair.
• If you feel unsafe due to lack of repairs, you can ask the Rental Office to order repairs or address the problem.

For a full summary of tenant laws and both parties’ rights, review Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

What Happens If You’re Unfairly Charged?

If you believe you are being unfairly charged for an emergency repair:

• Gather all documentation (texts, emails, repair invoices, photos)
• Try to resolve the dispute directly in writing with the landlord
• If unresolved, apply to the PEI Rental Office for a decision

If you want to move to a different rental, Find rental homes across Canada on Houseme for new listings in PEI and beyond.

FAQ: Emergency Repairs and Tenant Rights in PEI

1. Can my landlord make me pay for emergency repairs I didn’t cause?
   Generally, no. If you did not create the emergency by neglect or misuse, your landlord must pay.
2. What if I cannot reach my landlord during an emergency?
   You may arrange an essential repair yourself and seek reimbursement, but only after trying to reach your landlord and documenting your efforts.
3. What forms are used to resolve disputes over repair costs?
   Use the Application to the Director (Form 2A)—attach evidence showing you followed the process and are not at fault.
4. Can repairs be deducted from my security deposit?
   Only if you caused the damage. Otherwise, deposits should not be used for repair costs.
5. Who can help me if I feel unsafe due to lack of urgent repairs?
   Contact the PEI Rental Office for advice and to file a complaint if your landlord isn’t acting.

Key Takeaways

• Landlords in PEI are usually responsible for emergency repair costs unless the tenant caused the problem.
• Document your steps and use official forms if there is a dispute.
• Seek advice from the Rental Office if you feel your rights are not respected or if you’re unsure about cost responsibility.

Remember, being proactive and informed protects your rights and safety when emergencies happen.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• PEI Rental Office – Questions, complaint filings, and official forms
• PEI Housing Services – General rental housing support and updates
• Full Rental of Residential Property Act (PEI) – Review the current law

---

1. “Rental of Residential Property Act (PEI),” Government of Prince Edward Island. View the official legislation
2. PEI Rental Office. Rental Office tenant resources

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy