Key Pet Tenancy Dispute Cases in Nova Scotia: Tenant Guide

Pet ownership is common among Nova Scotia tenants, but disputes over animals in rentals are on the rise. As a tenant, knowing your rights and responsibilities is essential when it comes to keeping a pet in your rental unit. This article walks you through key legal precedents, provides practical steps if you face a dispute, and connects you to resources that help protect your tenancy and your pet.

Pet-Related Tenancy Laws in Nova Scotia

In Nova Scotia, the legality of keeping pets in rental units is primarily covered by the Residential Tenancies Act.^[1] This legislation gives landlords some discretion to set pet rules in lease agreements, but there are important exceptions and case law clarifying how these rules must be applied fairly.

Typical Lease Clauses and What They Mean

• Some leases include a 'no pets' policy. If you signed such a lease, having a pet without permission could be grounds for ending your tenancy.
• In other cases, landlords may allow pets but may set limits or conditions (e.g., size, type, number of animals).
• Even with a 'no pets' policy, Nova Scotia law can require exceptions for service animals or where enforcement is discriminatory.

For more detailed responsibilities of both tenants and landlords around lease rules, see Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained.

Key Cases: How Tribunals Decide Pet Disputes

Each pet-related tenancy case is unique, but Nova Scotia's Residential Tenancy Program (the official tribunal handling tenancy matters) regularly hears disputes about pets. Outcomes depend on lease terms, tenant behaviour, and health or safety impacts.

1. No-Pet Clauses and Tenant Protections

Past cases have shown that while landlords can include ‘no pets’ clauses, enforcing them strictly (especially for long-term tenants who have kept pets without complaint) may not always result in eviction. The tribunal looks at:

• Whether the tenant’s pet caused property damage or disturbances
• If the ‘no pets’ rule is enforced consistently for all tenants
• Whether the tenant tried to discuss issues or obtain consent before getting a pet

2. Service and Support Animals

Under provincial law and human rights protections, tenants with a disability who require a service animal may have a legal right to keep their animal, regardless of lease terms. Landlords must accommodate qualified service animal needs unless doing so causes undue hardship.

3. Damage, Disturbance, and Complaints

Cases involving pet-caused damage, excessive noise, or nuisance are common. The tribunal usually requires proof of:

• Actual property damage beyond normal wear and tear
• Documented neighbour complaints about noise, smell, or safety hazards
• Failure by the tenant to remedy the issue after warnings

Sometimes, complaints about pets can lead to attempts at eviction, but the Residential Tenancy Program weighs the evidence and strives for fairness. Learn more about issues and complaints in rentals in How to Handle Complaints in Your Rental: A Tenant’s Guide.

Your Action Steps if Facing a Pet Dispute

If your landlord raises concerns about a pet or issues a notice, staying calm and following official procedures improves your chances of a positive outcome.

• Review your lease for pet-related clauses and save all related communications
• If you receive an official Notice to Quit (Form C), you have seven days to apply to the Residential Tenancy Program to dispute the notice
• Document the pet’s behaviour, any efforts you made to prevent problems, and your communication with the landlord
• Prepare to attend a hearing if one is scheduled
• Seek support if your case involves a service animal or potential discrimination

Relevant Forms for Nova Scotia Tenants

• Form C: Notice to Quit – Used by a landlord to notify a tenant that they must vacate, often for breach of a pet clause or other rule.
  Download Form C - Notice to Quit
  Sample: If you receive this form due to a pet dispute, you have the right to challenge it by applying to the tribunal within 7 days.
• Application to Director (Form J) – Use this form to request a hearing at the Residential Tenancy Program to contest an eviction or dispute a landlord’s decision.
  Download Application to Director (Form J)
  Sample: If you believe your landlord is being unreasonable or discriminating against your support animal, file Form J as soon as possible.

How to Submit an Application to the Residential Tenancy Program

• Gather all evidence, including communications and pictures
• Fill out Form J with details of your dispute
• Submit your form to your local Access Nova Scotia office or by mail as indicated on the form
• Prepare to present your case at a hearing

Where to Get Official Guidance

The Residential Tenancy Program of Nova Scotia is the official government body overseeing landlord-tenant disputes. They also provide guidance on pets and other tenancy issues.

Other Important Considerations

• Landlords cannot require a “pet deposit” separate from the regular security deposit.
• Disputes involving health and safety (such as pets that cause pest infestations) may be treated differently—see Health and Safety Issues Every Tenant Should Know When Renting.
• For an overview of broad tenancy rights in your province, see Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Nova Scotia.

The province also has anti-discrimination measures which can influence pet disputes, especially for those with disabilities.

If you’re looking for a rental that welcomes pets, Search pet-friendly rentals on Houseme.ca.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can my landlord evict me just for having a pet in Nova Scotia?
   It depends on your lease terms and the circumstances. If you signed a lease with a ‘no pets’ clause and break it, your landlord can issue a Notice to Quit. However, you may challenge the eviction through the Residential Tenancy Program, especially if the pet is not causing harm or if there are exceptions such as for service animals.
2. Does the law protect my right to have a service animal?
   Yes, tenants with a verified disability who require a service animal are protected under Nova Scotia’s human rights laws. Landlords must make accommodations unless it creates undue hardship.
3. How do I dispute a Notice to Quit related to my pet?
   Respond within 7 days by filing an Application to Director (Form J) with the Residential Tenancy Program. Provide evidence supporting your case, such as proof your pet is not causing problems or that the rule is not being enforced fairly.
4. Can my landlord ask for an extra pet deposit?
   No. Under Nova Scotia law, landlords can only ask for a single security deposit (equal to no more than half a month’s rent), not an additional pet deposit.
5. I want to rent with a pet—how can I find pet-friendly apartments?
   Look for rentals that advertise as pet-friendly and always check your lease before bringing a pet home. For pet-welcoming listings, Search pet-friendly rentals on Houseme.ca.

Summary: Key Takeaways

• Pet disputes are common, but tenants have rights—especially regarding service animals and discrimination claims.
• Always check your lease terms and communicate with your landlord before adding a pet.
• Challenge any unfair eviction attempts by following official procedures with the Residential Tenancy Program.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Residential Tenancy Program of Nova Scotia – Forms, guides and contacts for disputes
• Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission – For disability or discrimination issues
• Legal Information Society of Nova Scotia – Free basic legal info and tenant resources
• How to Handle Complaints in Your Rental: A Tenant’s Guide
• Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Nova Scotia

---

1. Residential Tenancies Act (Nova Scotia): full legislation text
2. Official Residential Tenancy Program – Nova Scotia
3. Service Animals and the Law (Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission)
4. Form J: Application to Director – Nova Scotia
5. Form C: Notice to Quit – Nova Scotia

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy