Recognizing Illegal Evictions and Landlord Retaliation in PEI

If you have recently received an eviction notice or fear you may be evicted after asking for repairs or exercising your rights as a tenant in Prince Edward Island, it's important to know where you stand under the law. This guide explains how to recognize landlord retaliation, identify legal versus illegal evictions, and what steps to take if you believe your eviction was unfair.

Understanding Tenant Rights in Prince Edward Island

The laws that govern rentals and evictions in PEI are found in the Rental of Residential Property Act.^[1] This Act gives tenants important protections and spells out when a landlord can (and cannot) evict you.

If you're unsure about the basics—like notice periods, what reasons are valid for ending a tenancy, or your obligations—see Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island for a thorough overview.

What Is Landlord Retaliation?

Landlord retaliation happens when a landlord tries to evict or punish a tenant for exercising their legal rights, such as:

• Requesting repairs or maintenance
• Filing a formal complaint about health, safety, or bylaw issues
• Joining a tenants' association
• Reporting a landlord’s non-compliance with the law

Retaliatory evictions are not allowed under PEI law. If you suspect retaliation, read on for how to prove it and what to do next.

Legal and Illegal Reasons for Eviction

According to the Rental of Residential Property Act, a landlord can only terminate a tenancy for legitimate reasons, such as:

• Non-payment of rent
• Serious damage to the property
• The landlord or a close family member needs to move in (with proper notice)
• Major renovations that require the unit to be empty

The landlord must provide the correct written notice and follow all procedures set by the PEI Residential Rental Office.^[2]

Evictions are considered illegal if they are not for a reason allowed under the Act or do not follow notice requirements. Eviction as retaliation for complaints or asking for repairs is also illegal.

Common Signs of Retaliatory Eviction

• Your eviction notice arrives soon after you request repairs or complain to the landlord or authorities
• You are asked to leave without written notice or with a very short (less than legal minimum) notice period
• The notice claims reasons that aren't allowed by law ("because you complained," "because you asked for something expensive to be fixed," etc.)

Keeping records of your communications and repair requests is important if you need to challenge a retaliatory eviction.

How Eviction Notices Work in PEI

Landlords in PEI must use a formal Notice of Termination and provide the following minimum notice periods (unless the tenant is being evicted for significant cause such as illegal activity):

• For non-payment of rent: At least 20 days' written notice
• For renovations or the landlord’s own use: At least two months’ written notice

The official forms and requirements are available from the PEI Residential Rental Office—Forms. For example:

• Form 4: Notice of Termination by Lessor (PDF): Used when a landlord is ending the tenancy for a legal reason. If your landlord asks you to move out, ask to see this form. Note the stated reason and the notice period, and keep a copy for your records.
• Form 5: Application by Lessee (Tenant) (PDF): Use this if you want to challenge your eviction or claim that your landlord is retaliating. Submit the form to the Rental Office as soon as possible after receiving your notice.

What to Do If You Suspect Retaliation

If you believe your eviction is retaliatory, you can:

• Gather all documentation (emails, texts, letters, repair requests).
• File an Application by Lessee (Form 5) to dispute the notice with the Residential Rental Office.
• Continue paying rent on time and following the tenancy agreement while your case is being decided.
• Seek legal advice or assistance from tenant support organizations if needed.

Tenants and landlords both have clear rights and responsibilities in PEI. For a comprehensive breakdown, see Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained.

Other Common Tenant Issues

Landlord retaliation can arise after you request basic repairs, demand safe living conditions, or challenge issues like pests or emergency repairs. For advice on common disputes, see Common Issues Tenants Face and How to Resolve Them.

Looking to move or find a new place? Explore Houseme for nationwide rental listings to see current rental opportunities across Canada.

1. Can a landlord evict me for complaining about repairs?
   If you are evicted or threatened with eviction after requesting repairs or reporting issues, this could be landlord retaliation. Evictions for exercising your tenant rights are not allowed under Prince Edward Island law. You can challenge this by applying to the Rental Office.
2. What is the minimum notice period for eviction in PEI?
   It depends on the reason. The minimum is 20 days for non-payment of rent and at least two months for reasons like major renovations or the landlord’s own use. Notices must be in writing and use the official form.
3. How do I dispute an illegal eviction?
   Submit Form 5 (Application by Lessee) to the Residential Rental Office. Include all relevant documentation and clearly state why you believe the eviction is not legal, such as evidence of retaliation.
4. What should I do if my landlord ignores the law?
   Document everything, keep paying your rent, and contact the Rental Office for support. You may also seek help from local tenant advocacy organizations.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways for PEI Tenants

• Evictions must follow legal reasons and proper notice periods as stated in the Rental of Residential Property Act.
• Retaliatory evictions for reporting issues or exercising rights are not permitted.
• If you receive a questionable eviction notice, document everything and apply to the Residential Rental Office using official forms.

Knowing your rights and the proper steps can help you protect your home and respond effectively to unfair treatment.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• PEI Residential Rental Office: Handles tenancy disputes and provides forms.
• Rental of Residential Property Act: The law covering rental rights and responsibilities in PEI.
• Consumer, Labour and Financial Services: Can assist with complaints or further information.
• For a full overview, visit Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

1. PEI Government, Rental of Residential Property Act
2. PEI Office of the Attorney General, Residential Rental Office