Mediation vs Adjudication at Prince Edward Island's LTB

When tenant-landlord disputes arise in Prince Edward Island, tenants often turn to the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC), which functions as the province's Residential Tenancy Office. As a tenant, understanding your options—mediation or adjudication—can help you choose the fair and efficient path for resolving your issue. Whether you're facing a rent increase, maintenance dispute, or eviction, knowing how these processes work is crucial for protecting your rights under PEI's Rental of Residential Property Act^[1].

Understanding Mediation and Adjudication in PEI

Both mediation and adjudication are formal processes used by the IRAC to resolve disputes between tenants and landlords. Let's break down each process so you can understand the pros, cons, and best uses for your situation.

What is Mediation?

Mediation is a voluntary, confidential process where a neutral third-party mediator helps you and your landlord come to a mutual agreement. The mediator does not make decisions; instead, they guide the conversation to help both sides address issues and reach a solution.

• Voluntary: Both you and your landlord must agree to try mediation.
• Informal and Flexible: The process encourages open communication without rigid rules.
• Binding if Agreement is Reached: If you settle, the agreement is usually put in writing and is enforceable.
• Faster Resolution: Mediation can often resolve issues more quickly than a formal hearing.

This path may be best for disputes where ongoing relationships are important—such as maintenance issues, minor complaints, or payment arrangements.

What is Adjudication?

Adjudication is a formal process where an IRAC hearing officer (adjudicator) listens to both sides, reviews evidence, and makes a binding decision.

• Structured: Involves a formal hearing, evidence presentation, and sometimes witness testimony.
• Binding Decision: The adjudicator's ruling is enforceable under the Rental of Residential Property Act.
• Records and Appeals: Decisions create a record and can sometimes be appealed within specific timelines.

Adjudication is often necessary when disputes can't be resolved amicably, or for serious issues like eviction or major rule violations.

Key Differences at a Glance

• Mediation focuses on mutual agreement—informal and often faster.
• Adjudication gives a formal decision—structured, with rights of appeal.
• Mediation requires both parties to participate, while adjudication proceeds even if one side is absent.

If you’re unsure whether your issue is common, see Common Issues Tenants Face and How to Resolve Them.

How to Start the Process in PEI

All tenant-landlord dispute resolution in PEI is managed by the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC) through its Rental Office. To begin either mediation or adjudication, tenants typically file the relevant application form.

Essential Forms for Tenants

• Form 6: Application By Tenant

When to use: Use Form 6 to apply to IRAC if you have a dispute, such as disagreeing with a rent increase or an eviction notice.

• Download PEI Form 6: Application By Tenant

How it works: Complete the form with details about your situation (e.g., why you disagree with an action by your landlord) and submit it to IRAC. Once received, IRAC may attempt mediation first if both parties agree. If mediation fails or is declined, the matter will proceed to adjudication.

Which Process Should You Choose?

The right choice depends on your situation. For issues like rent increases, lack of repairs, or communication problems, mediation may lead to quick, agreeable solutions. If your dispute involves a legal question or you need an official decision (e.g., eviction challenges), adjudication may be necessary.

Things to Consider

• Is an ongoing relationship with your landlord important to you?
• Do you need a quick, private solution, or is a binding legal decision necessary?
• Are both sides willing to talk and compromise?

For a full understanding of tenant and landlord responsibilities, see Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained.

How Decisions Are Enforced

If you reach an agreement in mediation, it will be documented and enforceable by the IRAC Rental Office. For adjudication, the hearing officer’s decision is a legal order. If either party does not follow the order, the other can request IRAC's help with enforcement.

Your Rights and Protections

All mediation and adjudication proceedings are guided by the Rental of Residential Property Act, which sets out your rights and obligations as a tenant. For a full overview tailored to PEI, visit Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

For nationwide rental listings or to begin your next search, Find rental homes across Canada on Houseme.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is mediation required before going to adjudication in PEI?
   Mediation is not mandatory. It is offered if both tenant and landlord agree; otherwise, your case will go straight to adjudication.
2. Can I bring evidence or witnesses to the adjudication hearing?
   Yes. In adjudication, you can present documents, photos, and call witnesses to support your side.
3. How do I appeal a decision from adjudication?
   If you disagree with an adjudicator’s decision, you may have limited grounds and time to request a rehearing or appeal. Check your decision letter for instructions or contact IRAC for current procedures.
4. Will I need a lawyer for mediation or adjudication?
   No, both processes are designed to be accessible. You may represent yourself, but you can bring someone to help if you choose.

Key Takeaways

• PEI tenants can choose mediation (informal, collaborative) or adjudication (formal, binding decision).
• Start either process by submitting the correct form to IRAC's Rental Office.
• All proceedings follow the Rental of Residential Property Act to safeguard your rights.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• PEI Residential Tenancy Office – Tenant Information: Guidance, forms, and contact details
• Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC): Provincial tribunal for all rental disputes
• PEI Government – Rental Property Information: Fact sheets and legislative details
• Local legal clinics or tenant support groups (check PEI community resources)

---

1. Rental of Residential Property Act (PEI)

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy