Landlord vs. Tenant Insurance in Prince Edward Island

Understanding the difference between landlord and tenant insurance is essential for anyone renting in Prince Edward Island. Many tenants are surprised to learn that their landlord’s insurance does not cover their personal belongings or their liability as a renter. This article breaks down who covers what, how to protect yourself, and what resources are available to help tenants feel secure throughout their tenancy.

Understanding Insurance: What Does Each Policy Cover?

Both landlord and tenant insurance provide important protections, but they serve different purposes. Here’s a breakdown of what each type of insurance usually covers in Prince Edward Island:

Landlord Insurance

• Covers: The structure of the building, fixtures, outbuildings, and, in most cases, landlord-owned appliances or furnishings.
• Does not cover: Tenant's personal belongings or liability for things tenants do.
• May include loss of rental income if a property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event (like fire or flood).

Tenant Insurance (Renter's Insurance)

• Personal Contents Coverage: Protects your belongings (such as clothes, electronics, and furniture) from events like fire, theft, or water damage.
• Liability Coverage: Protects you if you accidentally damage the landlord’s property or if someone gets hurt while visiting your rental unit and you are found responsible.
• Additional Living Expenses: Helps with temporary housing costs if your rental becomes uninhabitable due to an insured peril.

Landlords in Prince Edward Island are not legally required to insist tenants carry insurance, but they may include it as a requirement in your lease. Always review your rental agreement carefully before signing. For more details about what to watch for when moving in, see Essential Tips for Tenants When Moving Into a New Rental Home.

Who Is Responsible for What? A Closer Look

• Landlords: Responsible for insuring the building and their own property. Not responsible for tenant belongings or liability claims arising from tenant activities.
• Tenants: Responsible for insuring their own belongings and protecting themselves against liability claims. Without coverage, you may have to pay out of pocket if you cause damage or if there’s an accident.

To fully understand your responsibilities and those of your landlord, visit Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained and review Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

What PEI Law Says About Insurance and Liability

Prince Edward Island’s main law governing tenancies is the Landlord and Tenant Act (PEI).^[1] This legislation sets out basic rights and responsibilities for landlords and tenants but does not require either party to purchase specific insurance. However, landlords may request proof of tenant insurance as a condition of your lease.

The tribunal that handles tenancy matters is the Residential Tenancy Office (PEI Department of Justice and Public Safety).^[2]

Dealing with Damages and Liability

If damage occurs due to a tenant’s action or negligence (for example, starting a kitchen fire), the tenant may be held responsible for covering repair costs. This is where tenant insurance helps protect you financially. If there’s ever a dispute about who is responsible for damage or repairs, you can contact the Residential Tenancy Office for advice.

Official Forms and How to Use Them

While there is no PEI-specific government form just for tenant insurance, several forms are connected to your rights and responsibilities regarding repairs and liability:

• Form 6 – Application by Landlord or Tenant:
  • When to use: If there is a dispute over property damage, responsibility, or compensation, either the landlord or tenant can submit this form to the Residential Tenancy Office.
  • Example: If your landlord claims you caused water damage and you disagree, you can apply for a hearing.
  • Find Form 6 on the PEI government website
• Condition Report Form:
  • When to use: This report records the condition of the property at move-in and move-out, which can affect disputes over liability or deductions.
  • Example: Complete and sign with your landlord when moving in and out to document any existing or new damage.
  • Download the Condition Report Form here

Action Steps for Tenants

• Ask your landlord whether tenant insurance is required as part of your lease.
• Shop around for a tenant insurance policy that covers both your contents and liability.
• Carefully read your lease and insurance policy to understand exclusions or special conditions.
• Keep receipts and photos of your belongings for insurance claims.
• Use the Residential Tenancy Office’s forms if a dispute arises over damage or repairs.

Protecting Yourself Beyond Insurance

Besides having a good insurance policy, keep track of property inspections and document any issues when moving in. This protects you if questions arise later. For a closer look at inspections, check out the Guide to the Initial Rental Property Inspection for Tenants.

For tenants searching for their next rental, Browse apartments for rent in Canada to find safe, up-to-date listings nationwide.

FAQs: Landlord and Tenant Insurance in PEI

1. Is tenant insurance mandatory in Prince Edward Island?
   Tenant insurance is not required by PEI law but may be required by your landlord as a lease condition.
2. If my belongings are stolen or damaged, does my landlord pay?
   No, your landlord’s insurance does not cover your personal items. Tenant insurance is needed for that protection.
3. Does tenant insurance cover accidental damage to the apartment?
   Yes, if the policy includes liability coverage. Always check with your provider to understand what's covered.
4. What happens if I can’t stay in my apartment after a fire?
   Tenant insurance policies with additional living expenses coverage can help pay for temporary accommodation.
5. Who do I contact if I have a dispute about damages with my landlord?
   You should apply to the Residential Tenancy Office in PEI using the relevant form (such as Form 6).

Conclusion: Key Takeaways

• Landlord insurance protects the building, not the tenant’s possessions or liability.
• Tenant insurance is an affordable way to safeguard personal belongings and cover liability risks.
• The PEI Landlord and Tenant Act outlines basic rights, while the Residential Tenancy Office resolves disputes.

Understanding your coverage helps prevent surprises and supports a positive renting experience for everyone.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Residential Tenancy Office – PEI (Tribunal for landlord-tenant disputes and official forms)
• PEI Housing Services (Tenant help and information)
• Community Legal Information (PEI) (Free legal info for tenants)

---

1. Landlord and Tenant Act (PEI)
2. Residential Tenancy Office – PEI

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy