Consequences of Not Having Tenant Insurance in PEI

Many tenants in Prince Edward Island wonder whether they really need tenant insurance. While PEI law does not require tenants to carry insurance, not having it can leave you exposed to significant financial, legal, and practical risks throughout your tenancy. This article explains the consequences you may face when renting without tenant insurance in Prince Edward Island, what landlords can and cannot demand, and how to better safeguard yourself during your rental experience.

Is Tenant Insurance Required in Prince Edward Island?

Tenant insurance is not a legal requirement under the Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act ^[1]. The legislation does not mention or mandate tenant insurance. However, landlords can include a requirement for tenant insurance in your lease agreement. Always review your rental agreement carefully to see if this is a condition.

Even if it’s not required, many landlords strongly recommend or expect tenants to have at least basic liability coverage.

What Happens If You Do Not Have Tenant Insurance?

The biggest consequences of not having tenant insurance in PEI include:

• Financial risk: You’ll need to pay out-of-pocket for any damage you accidentally cause to your unit or the building (for example, fire or water damage).
• No coverage for your belongings: If your possessions are lost due to fire, theft, or flood, you will not be compensated unless you have insurance.
• Liability claims: If someone is injured in your unit, or damage spreads to another unit, you may be held personally responsible for damages and legal fees.
• Potential breach of lease: If your lease specifically requires tenant insurance and you fail to provide proof, your landlord could issue a warning, and in some situations, may seek to terminate the tenancy following proper process.

How It Relates to Landlord and Tenant Responsibilities

Landlords in PEI are responsible for insuring the building and their own property, but you are responsible for your personal property and any accidental damage you cause to the unit or building.
If your agreement requires insurance and you do not comply, it may put you in breach of the lease—and landlords could take further action if the situation is not resolved. Read more about your Obligations of Landlords and Tenants: Rights and Responsibilities Explained to better understand your role and responsibilities.

Does Tenant Insurance Protect Against All Problems?

No insurance policy covers every situation. Tenant insurance generally covers:

• Your personal possessions (for losses like fire or theft)
• Personal liability (if someone is injured or if property damage occurs)
• Additional living expenses (if you can’t stay in your home due to a covered event)

It does not cover building-related damage that is the landlord’s responsibility or issues arising from poor maintenance. For other concerns, like maintenance issues or repairs, see Emergency Situations and Repairs: Tenant Rights and Responsibilities.

Who Handles Disputes or Issues in PEI?

In Prince Edward Island, residential tenancy disputes are overseen by the Office of Residential Rental Property^[2].

Relevant Forms and Action Steps for Tenants

There are no specific government forms in PEI just for tenant insurance. However, if your landlord claims you’ve breached your lease by not having insurance, they may serve you a formal notice.

• Form 6: Application by a Landlord – Used by the landlord to apply to end a tenancy or claim damages if you’re not meeting lease terms (like lacking required insurance).
  When to use: If you receive a copy, respond promptly. If you disagree, prepare to present your case at a tribunal hearing.
  Download Form 6: Application by a Landlord (PEI government)

Tips for Tenants in PEI

• Review your lease carefully before signing—ask if tenant insurance is required or recommended.
• Shop around for different policies to find affordable coverage. Many banks and insurance companies provide easy online quotes.
• Keep your insurance documents handy, as your landlord may request proof.
• Document your belongings with photos or lists in case you need to make a claim.

Having insurance is not just about protecting your stuff—it’s about protecting yourself from possible lawsuits or expensive mishaps out of your control.

For more details about all aspects of renting in your province, see Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

Looking for a new rental in PEI or across the country? Find rental homes across Canada on Houseme with ease.

FAQ: Tenant Insurance in Prince Edward Island

1. Is tenant insurance legally required in PEI?
   No, tenant insurance is not required by law in Prince Edward Island, but it may be required by your lease.
2. Can my landlord evict me for not having tenant insurance?
   If your lease says insurance is required and you do not provide proof, your landlord may issue a notice and apply to end the tenancy after following official process.
3. What does tenant insurance usually cover?
   Typical policies cover your personal belongings, liability (if you accidentally damage the property or another person’s property), and additional living expenses if your unit is temporarily uninhabitable.
4. Will the landlord’s insurance cover my possessions?
   No, the landlord’s insurance only covers the building. Your personal property is your own responsibility.
5. What should I do if my landlord asks for proof of insurance?
   Provide a copy of your insurance policy or a certificate from your insurer to your landlord within the required timeline stated in your lease.

Key Takeaways: Protecting Yourself as a Tenant in PEI

• Tenant insurance protects you financially from accidents, liability, and unexpected loss of belongings.
• PEI law does not require tenant insurance, but your landlord or lease may.
• Understand your rights, responsibilities, and what your insurance policy will and will not cover.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

• Office of Residential Rental Property (PEI): Residential Rental Property Services – Information on tenant and landlord rights, disputes, and accessing official forms.
• Community Legal Information: Legal Info PEI – Provides plain language legal information and support for tenants.
• For more information about all tenant rights in PEI, visit our page on Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

---

1. Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act
2. Office of Residential Rental Property (PEI Government)

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent & Deposits Leases & Agreements Moving In / Out Maintenance & Repairs Evictions Roommates & Shared Housing Discrimination & Accessibility Utilities & Services Affordable Housing & Subsidies Dispute Resolution & LTB Safety & Security Privacy & Entry by Landlord Special Tenancy Situations Tenant Insurance & Liability Post-Eviction Resources Landlord Compliance & Penalties Legal Precedents & Case Summaries Mental Health & Tenancy