Can Landlords Deny Tenancy for Bad Credit in PEI? Your Rights Explained

Worried that a poor credit score might jeopardize your housing search in Prince Edward Island? Many prospective tenants have concerns about how credit checks affect their ability to secure a rental. This article breaks down your rights, explains what landlords can and can't consider, and offers practical steps if you face discrimination due to bad credit in PEI.

How Credit Checks Work for Rentals in PEI

Landlords in Prince Edward Island commonly require a credit check as part of the rental application process. These checks help landlords assess a tenant’s ability to pay rent reliably. However, they must still follow rules under provincial tenancy law and Canadian human rights standards.

Are Landlords Allowed to Deny Housing for Bad Credit?

In most cases, landlords in PEI can consider your credit history when deciding to accept or refuse your application. A poor credit report may reduce your chances, but this alone is not legally considered discrimination. However, there are important limits and protections:

  • Informed consent: Landlords must get your written consent before performing a credit check.
  • Consistent application: The same approval criteria should apply to all applicants, regardless of race, gender, age, or other protected grounds.
  • No discrimination: Denying your application solely based on a protected characteristic combined with bad credit (for example, refusing only newcomers with credit challenges) may violate human rights rules.

The law in PEI protects tenants against unequal treatment, even during application screening. Learn more about your rights under Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island.

Your Rights Under the Prince Edward Island Rental of Residential Property Act

Housing rights on PEI are governed by the Rental of Residential Property Act and enforced by the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC)'s Residential Rental Property Office (IRAC Residential Rental Property Division)[1]. While the Act doesn’t specifically address credit checks, it requires all rental applicants be treated fairly and without discrimination.

When Is It Discrimination?

If you believe you were denied an apartment because of a protected ground like race, gender, age, or disability (not just bad credit), you may have a case for discrimination. Bad credit by itself does not fall under a protected ground, but if a landlord uses it as a cover for unlawful discrimination, you have rights under the PEI Human Rights Act.

Tip: If you suspect unfair treatment, ask your landlord for specific reasons why your application was denied and keep a written record of all correspondence.

Alternative Solutions if You Have Bad Credit

Here are some potential options if you’re struggling to get approved due to poor credit:

  • Offer a co-signer or guarantor with strong credit.
  • Show proof of current income, employment, or savings.
  • Provide strong references from previous landlords.
  • Offer a larger rental deposit (within legal limits—see Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know for rules in PEI).
  • Request a shorter-term lease to prove reliability.

Keep in mind, deposits in PEI are strictly regulated under the Act, so landlords cannot ask for more than is legally permitted.

Ad

Making a Complaint about Discrimination or Unfair Screening

If you suspect a landlord denied your application for reasons beyond just bad credit and feel it violates human rights law, here are your options:

  • File a complaint with the PEI Human Rights Commission: Use the official complaint form. Describe why you believe you faced discrimination and attach any evidence (e.g., written communication or ads).
  • Ask IRAC’s Residential Rental Property Office for guidance: While they do not handle discrimination complaints directly, they offer advice about the Rental of Residential Property Act and your housing rights.

Example: If a landlord denies your tenancy, refuses to explain, and you suspect it’s because you’re a single parent (a protected ground), you could contact the Human Rights Commission even if they referenced bad credit as the reason.

Which Official Forms Should Tenants Know?

  • Rental Application (no standard form number): Always review and request a copy. If asked for a credit check, ensure you give written consent.
  • Complaint Form (PEI Human Rights Commission): Use when you believe housing discrimination occurred. Find the form here. Complete with evidence and submit to the address listed on the website.
  • Application to Director: Rental Property (Form 2): If you have a dispute during or after accepting a tenancy, use this form to ask the Director at IRAC to resolve the matter. See Form 2 on IRAC’s official forms page.

Key Tips to Strengthen Your Rental Application

While credit is an important factor, it’s not the only one. Increase your chances by:

  • Being upfront about any financial challenges and offering explanations.
  • Providing consistent documentation for income, references, and employment history.
  • Exploring Explore Houseme for nationwide rental listings to find landlords with more flexible application processes.

Finding a home can be challenging but knowing your rights helps you navigate the process with confidence.

FAQ: Tenants and Credit Checks in PEI

  1. Can a landlord request a credit check without my consent?
    No. In PEI, landlords must have your written consent before running a credit check as part of the rental application process.
  2. Is bad credit considered a ground for discrimination under PEI law?
    Not on its own. However, if bad credit is used as a pretext to discriminate based on race, age, family status, etc., this may violate the Human Rights Act.
  3. If my application is denied for bad credit, can I appeal?
    You cannot formally appeal a landlord’s refusal for bad credit, but you can file a human rights complaint if you suspect discrimination.
  4. Can a landlord ask for additional deposits because of bad credit?
    No. Rental deposits are regulated. See Understanding Rental Deposits: What Tenants Need to Know for what’s permitted.
  5. Where can I find more about my rights as a tenant in PEI?
    Check out Tenant Rights and Landlord Rights in Prince Edward Island for an overview of protections under the law.

Key Takeaways

  • Landlords in PEI can consider credit but cannot discriminate based on personal characteristics protected by law.
  • You have the right to written consent for credit checks and must be treated fairly during the application process.
  • If you face suspected discrimination, file a complaint with the PEI Human Rights Commission and seek advice from IRAC’s Residential Rental Property Office.

Brief summary: Understanding the balance between credit checks and your rights as a tenant can help you avoid unfair treatment and find a suitable home faster.

Need Help? Resources for Tenants

  1. Prince Edward Island: Rental of Residential Property Act
  2. Official tenancy tribunal: IRAC - Residential Rental Property Office
  3. PEI Human Rights Commission: https://www.peihumanrights.ca/

Related Articles